6 dead in their beds: The true crime behind ‘The Amityville Horror’

Ronald DeFeo Jr., center, leaves Suffolk County district court after a hearing on New York's Long Island.
Ronald DeFeo Jr., center, leaves Suffolk County district court after a hearing on New York's Long Island. Credit: AP Photo/Richard Drew

“This is as close to Hell as I ever want to get,” Vera Farmiga as Lorraine Warren says near the beginning of “The Conjuring 2.” She’s talking about the house at 112 Ocean Ave. in Amityville, New York, which became the center of the alleged haunting (more likely hoax) detailed in the 1977 book (and subsequent films) “The Amityville Horror,” making it probably the most well-known “true” haunting in American history.

In the movie, Lorraine has just witnessed a vision of Ronald DeFeo Jr. slaughtering his family with a rifle — the event that kicked off the supposed haunting. “The Conjuring 2” suggests that he did so under the influence of a demonic entity.

Demon or no, the fact is that someone wiped out most of the DeFeo family in the early morning of Nov. 13, 1974, while they were sleeping in their beds. And the most likely culprit was the only surviving member of the family, 23-year-old Ronald DeFeo Jr.

Around 6:30 p.m. that evening, DeFeo Jr. came running into Henry’s Bar and claimed that his family had been shot. Several people left the bar and followed DeFeo to the family’s home at 112 Ocean Ave. At 6:35 p.m., one of the men frantically called the police, describing the grisly scene.

Editor's Picks

  1. 3 brothers vanished in 2010. Why is their father facing murder charges now?The Dispatch
  2. The real-life Texas sting behind Robert Pattinson’s ‘Primetime’ ended in deathCulture Docket
  3. Where is Rae Carruth’s son now? Chancellor Lee Adams wins Special Olympics goldCrimes Through Time

In all, six bodies were found in the DeFeo home. According to the Suffolk County police, all were found face-down in their beds, all killed with bullets from a Marlin 336C rifle. The victims were DeFeo Jr.’s parents, Ronald DeFeo Sr., 43, and Louise DeFeo, 42, and his four siblings, Dawn, Allison, Marc and John, all aged between 9 and 18 years.

Ronald DeFeo Jr. stands handcuffed on the steps of a sheriff’s van as officers escort him to his arraignment.
Ronald DeFeo Jr., standing on the steps of a sheriff’s van, arrives for his arraignment in Hauppauge, New York, on six counts of murder on Nov. 18, 1974. Credit: Frank Mooney/New York Daily News/TNS

Initially, Ronald DeFeo claimed that his family had been the victims of a mob hit. The DeFeos had ties to the Genovese crime family — one of the “Five Families” that dominated organized crime in New York and New Jersey. He was taken into protective custody, but holes began to appear in his story almost immediately, and by the following day, he had confessed to committing all six murders. “It all started so fast,” DeFeo told investigators. “Once I started, I just couldn’t stop. It went so fast.”

Mugshot taken of Ronald DeFeo Jr., taken following his arrest on Nov. 14, 1974.
Mugshot taken of Ronald DeFeo Jr., taken following his arrest on Nov. 14, 1974.

Within a year, DeFeo Jr. was on trial for what the judge described as the “most heinous” murders ever committed in Suffolk County. DeFeo’s defense argued that he had no memory of the crimes, and employed psychiatrist Daniel Schwartz to testify that DeFeo was not guilty by reason of insanity. Schwartz would later famously work on the “Son of Sam” case in 1977.

Despite this, on Friday, Nov. 21, 1975 — only a little more than a year after that gruesome night — DeFeo Jr. was found guilty of six counts of second-degree murder. Though inconsistencies continued to haunt the case, and DeFeo changed his story numerous times over the years, he would spend the rest of his life in prison, dying in state custody in 2021 at the age of 69.

The month after DeFeo’s trial, George and Kathy Lutz and their three children became the first people to move into the house at 112 Ocean Ave. since the murders. Twenty-eight days later, they fled the property, claiming to have spent their tenure harassed by supernatural phenomena. A parade of psychic investigators would subsequently visit what simply became known as the “Amityville house,” among them Ed and Lorraine Warren.

While much of the alleged haunting has since been dismissed as a hoax, it quickly came to overshadow the horror of what had really taken place in Amityville on Nov. 13, 1974. But it needn’t have. Six dead bodies, the youngest only 9 years old, gunned down in cold blood while they slept, is more than horrific enough …

Share
Scroll to Top