Could ‘Grand Theft Auto VI’ actually help decrease crime? The game’s Nov. 19 launch could test the theory 

Lucia fires a weapon from a convertible driven by Jason in Grand Theft Auto VI.
Jason and Lucia, the protagonists of Rockstar Games’ “Grand Theft Auto VI.” Credit: USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

The latest iteration of the wildly popular video game “Grand Theft Auto” launches tomorrow, Nov. 19. And early reviews are calling “GTA VI” a masterpiece.

With critics praising the game’s unprecedented scale, technical achievements and emotional depth, all of which have exceeded the expectations built over the last 13 years since “GTA V” was released, “GTA VI” is currently boasting a near-perfect 99 out of 100 Metacritic score, tying “The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time” for the highest ever score recorded and surpassing all previous Rockstar titles.

Blending fictional worlds with real-life locations, events, characters and even crimes, the game offers players a satirical yet recognizably familiar experience. But there’s an even more interesting link to the real world. Some studies suggest that playing the crime-oriented game featuring virtual violence, car theft and mayhem might actually help decrease crime in the real world. 

‘Grand Theft Auto’ might have a surprising benefit 

Ethan Mollick, a Wharton School associate professor and AI researcher known for his work on how artificial intelligence affects work, entrepreneurship and education, took to X (formerly Twitter)in June 2023 to explore the correlation between playing violent video games and actually committing real crimes.

Editor's Picks

  1. 3 brothers vanished in 2010. Why is their father facing murder charges now?The Dispatch
  2. The real-life Texas sting behind Robert Pattinson’s ‘Primetime’ ended in deathCulture Docket
  3. Where is Rae Carruth’s son now? Chancellor Lee Adams wins Special Olympics goldCrimes Through Time

“Everyone freaked out for years that violent video games made kids violent, but it turns out that they probably don’t have any big effects,” Mollick wrote in his post. “The consensus of most large studies of violent games (using real game play data, not lab tests) shows no big impact on real-life aggression.” 

He then cited a study from Molecular Psychiatry that explored the question, “Does playing violent video games cause aggression?” 

In a follow-up post, Mollick linked the study directly to “GTA,” writing, “It gets better: Grand Theft Auto games lower crime rates. When a GTA game is released, violence & crime actually drop, as potential criminals stay inside to play (This applies to other big shooters, too, so the yearly CoD releases are actually good for the world, sorry to say).”

The effect, or concept, Mollick referenced is real, and it has a name. It’s called voluntary incapacitation. The basic idea is that people who spend hours playing a new game may spend less time out in public, potentially reducing opportunities to commit certain offenses. 

Of course, this isn’t an argument that violent games make people less violent. It’s about how people spend their time. Despite the studies not outright proving their hypotheses, it is an interesting take on violent video games. 

Another study, titled “The Release of Grand Theft Auto V and Registered Juvenile Crime in the Netherlands,” published in 2017 in the European Journal of Criminology, examined registered offenses from 2012 to 2014 among males ages 12 to 18 and 18 to 25 in the Netherlands. 

The key finding, shared by authors Marinus G.C.J. Beerthuizen, Gijs Weijters and André M. van der Laan, claimed that the release of “GTA V” in September 2013 was negatively associated with registered offenses in both age groups. The authors cautioned that the finding does not prove playing “GTA” caused crime to decline

The debate about video games and crime is ongoing

Of course, not everyone is on board with the idea that “GTA” and games similar to the franchise are actually crime busters. A more recent paper shared in October of this year found no detectable crime drop around major “GTA” and “Red Dead” releases in four U.S. cities. We should note that this is a working paper and not yet a published study or peer-reviewed research. So, more to come on that one.

Still, come Nov. 19, “GTA VI” offers another opportunity to examine the theory, but it’s too soon to predict what will happen to crime rates. For now, we can at least sleep soundly at night knowing that a game that lets its players run wild in a fictional criminal underworld might, at least temporarily, keep some of the bad guys busy at home.

Share
Scroll to Top